[Karkat, John is giving you a look that clearly suggests that he doubts your sanity. You did not just say that. You seriously did not just suggest that he put dear, sweet Casey into a pokéball.]

Yes I did, there was no way I was going to leave her in that room alone.

[Had he put out food for Dave's pokemon like Rose said, she wouldn't have been alone. But he had decided against it, instead putting them all in their balls and bringing them with him. He didn't like the idea of leaving Dave's balls unprotected.]

Besides it's not like she's hurting anything.